Skip to main content

Shame as Punishment

As I was reading through a book on coding today (Saldana's, for the record), I was reminded of an idea I'd had previously.  He used an example a study on oppression among teenagers.  This reminded me of a previous roommate of mine who did her thesis on the presence of shame and its effects in certain situations.  In reflecting on that idea since then, I've realized that we as a society sometimes use shame to modify behavior.  For example, if someone is wearing an outfit or sporting a hairstyle we consider strange and thus socially unacceptable, we ostracize or verbally demean them.

The shocking thing?  Using shame as a modifier has little to no effect on behavior that I've ever observed.  However, our attempts to reform someone through applying shame seem to take effect in the way they feel about themselves.  It is obviously not an effective strategy and shouldn't be employed even if it was.  Awareness about this issue might prove helpful not only to adults, but especially to children.

Comments

  1. Now that I've posted, I can finally see clearly what I should have said! Said another way, I believe we use shame as a form of oppression.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

If At First You Don't Succeed . . .

The Big Idea Canvas This was such an eye-opening exercise.  Being the overachiever I am, I was secretly hoping for a great score at the end and of course was totally bummed when I didn't get it.  However, that's probably the best thing that could have happened to me as I feeling quite comfortable with my idea and liking it really well.  After the Big Idea Canvas blew up in my face, I looked back at my idea and felt more like, "Who let YOU in here?  Shoo!  Shoo!" The biggest takeaway from the exercise was that my idea wasn't really innovative at all.  The problem I had identified is that there seems to be a hole in the school system where career exploration should be.  This hole is supposed to be filled by school counselors, most of whom have entirely too much on their plates already.  So, I decided it would be wise to fill the said hole with exactly the same thing: a substitute for a school counselor.  Thus, my solution was exactly the opp...

The Risk Test

This post will be particularly good for me as I tend to be an eternal optimist, which means I sometimes fail to consider the downsides of any idea.  Here goes! Is someone else already working on this problem?  If so, how are they doing? School of One is focused on offering each student a personalized education.  However, since their model is based on an algorithm, from what I've seen, students spend most of their day at a computer.  That's an idea I can't get on board with.  On the other hand, the philosophies and practices at High Tech High   seem to match well the ideas I've had, including giving students the chance to explore their own personal interests through projects.  I will definitely be doing some more looking into this option! If others have failed in solving this problem, why did they fail? I believe most charter schools are founded on the idea of doing things differently.  However, from my experience, they end up doing the same...

Episode 2: Bridge is Going to Be Your Best Friend

This is a screenshot of how I set up my photo files in Bridge.